Packers Playoff Pain Part 3
I was torn making this one. Do I go back to the crashing truck comic I used just last week with the Cowboys and make a version of the Packers crashing after they hit the 49ers? Or do I dig out this other Packer personalized chestnut and add onto it. Whatever I chose, the joke was PACKERS PLAYOFF PAIN.
It’s kind of incredible that since 2012 the Packers have gotten owned by the 49ers in the playoffs 5 times and never once beat them. The last time Green Bay actually managed to beat the 49ers in the playoffs, it was 2002. Brett Favre era. Their all-time record against the 49ers in the playoffs is 4-6 with most wins coming in the 90’s. So before 2012, they were actually 4-1 against SF. Then Kaepernick styled on them twice in back-to-back years. The 49ers would go and have a coaching/ownership meltdown that imploded the team, spent a few years toiling with the likes of Jim Tomsula and Chip Kelly (remember that?) before building back up into the current regime and spanking the Pack every other year since 2019. The 49ers have become the Packers Achilles heel. It is very funny.
This most recent loss is probably the least embarassing of the bunch, to be fair. The Pack were a 7th seed, running hot on house money with what is sort of a pseudo rookie QB and they went up against the top seed in the conference and put up a respectable fight. I think the 2021 loss is probably the most embarassing. The MVP couldn’t score a single touchdown as the #1 seed got punked at home by Jimmy G. The 2019 was also a beatdown that the score does not properly reflect (It started 27-0).
Quick aside, it’s funny watching the 2019 replay and seeing Raheem Mostert kicking ass. I think Raheem Mostert might be one of the most underrated RBs out there and he’s been doing it for longer than we realize.
Actually let’s have some more fun at the Packers expense and try to rank all the playoff losses since 2010 by order of least embarassing to most.
—
–2015 vs Cardinals: The Hail Mary game that sent the matchup into overtime and was only ended thanks to Larry Fitzgerald heroics. The Packers were a wildcard and the Cardinals a 2-seed. This was an outstanding game that everyone involved can be proud to have played in. I made a comic about how good it was.
–2023 vs 49ers: Just happened, as stated above. The game was between the top seed in the conference and a team that wouldn’t have even made the playoffs before a few seasons ago. The Packers weren’t even supposed to be here and they made a real match out of it. Ended really funny though with that cross-body INT.
–2013 vs 49ers: Despite being the home team, the Packers were a measly 8-7-1 and the visiting Kaeperniners were 12-4. The game wasn’t nearly the clinic Kaep put on the year before and it was an ugly slugfest in the cold.
-2012 vs 49ers: The “Kaepernick runs all over them” game. Divisional round, Pack was the visiting 3 seed to SF’s 2 seed. The game was actually pretty good till SF opened it up in the 3rd and the big difference in the game would end up being Green Bay’s inability to contain the leaping gazelle that was Kaep at full speed.
-2020 vs Bucs: Rodgers was MVP. Green Bay was the top seed in the conference. They faced the Goat, carrying the 5th seed Bucs into his first-ever NFCCG. This game was fairly good, but is remembered because Green Bay was down 31-23 with 2 minutes left, 4th down on the 8-yard line, and Matt LaFeur kicked a field goal. They were down 8 points with 2 minutes left, on the 8 yard line, and kicked a field goal. The Packers never got the ball back after a stupid holding by a defender gave Tampa the first down and they ran out the clock.
-2016 vs Falcons: Now it starts getting genuinely hard to rank to rank by embarrassments. The Packers were the 4 seed, had beaten the Giants and upset the Cowboys in a thriller. But then they ran into the 2-seed Falcons buzzsaw and got absolutely erased. Getting that far in the first place was a decent accomplishment and I’d say nobody was beating that Falcons team in 2016 but we know how that ended.
-2019 vs 49ers: The other time GB got trampled. The Niners were the 1 seed, the Packers the 2, they met in the championship and Green Bay looked like a team that deserved to miss the playoffs. 27-0 start for the 49ers, the game was never in doubt.
-2011 vs Giants: Packers were 15-1. They were the defending champions. Rodgers was the MVP. The Giants were a 9 win 4th seed that squeaked into the playoffs. The Packers completely forgot how to hold onto a football and the Giants handily beat them. The game even included a last second hail mary touchdown from Eli to Hakeem Nicks right before half. The refs in that game made one of the worst calls I’ve ever seen to this day in favor of the Packers when Greg Jennings clearly fumbled a ball but even on replay said he was down. That was one of the times I’ve been truly, utterly frothing mad at the refs after a bad call against my team. Eat shit Bill Levy. I’m glad the call wouldn’t matter in the end. First 15-1 zero playoff win team in history. Lol.
-2021 vs 49ers: 49ers were the 6th seed. Packers were once again the #1 seed. 13-4. Rodgers was once again MVP of the league. The season was marred by Rodgers getting exposed as a conspiracy nutter halfway through the year, a public embarrassment that sticks with him to this day as he’s only gone further down the rabbit hole, pissing off basically everyone except the nutters who believe the same things he does. The reigning MVP could do no right against the upstart 49ers in the frigid temperatures. The game wasn’t even that good, it was ugly and shitty. The 49ers didn’t play a great game (At least on offense). The play of the game was a blocked punt TD. They scored a rushing TD very early and never saw the endzone again. I watched this game with my 49ers fan neighbor and had an absolutely outstanding time. When I posted my cartoon of that game I got more likes on twitter than I had ever gotten before. The entire country was collectively relishing the demise of that jackass.
-2014 vs Seahawks: Some of these games listed above are arguably more embarrassing due to circumstances. A 1-seed losing to a wildcard, a 15-1 titan going down to a 9 win team. Getting buzzsawed before having a chance. This game is different and is probably, for the wrong reasons, the most memorable of them all for the one play. You know the play. Rodgers was once again MVP. Packers were the 2 seed to Seattle’s 1st seed. The game was a mess…in favor of the Packers. Neither team could stop turning the ball over but the Packers were the only ones to truly capitalize. The Seahawks only points through most of the 4th quarter were on a fake field goal. Ha-Ha Clinton-Dix caught the final of his many Russ picks with 5 minutes left and from the way it was going that really felt like the end. Narrator: it was not the end. Seattle got the ball back with 3:30 left. They scored with 2:09 left. That’s when it happened. The Seahawks kick onsides and Brandon Bostick makes the play he’ll be remembered for in the history books. The ball doinks off his head and into the arms of the Hawks. They’d score within a minute and make a miracle 2pt conversion to go up by 3. The Packers mustered a field goal to send it to overtime, but the damage was done. Russ threw one of his best ever passes to seal the deal on the first drive of OT. The Bostick Onside Kick is now legend and the Packers embarassment final.
If you are a Packers fan and read this whole post, I’m proud of you.
You too have felt the sting of Bill Levy and his horrible officiating. Be glad it was just one call in a game your team won rather than every single important play for the entire Super Bowl.
Was waiting for this one 🙂 Though I do have to disagree with your rating, that 2012 Niners atrocity deserves to be ranked as more embarassing as one of the worst defensive performances in playoff history. Like, you _knew_ what kind of offense you’d be facing and their reaction to “Well Kaep is running all over us” apparently was to go “Yeah let’s let him run I’m sure he’ll get tired after five to ten more touchdowns!”, that was really the moment when the structural problem of “We don’t really have to fix our problems we have ARod I’m sure he’ll hero ball us out of there” first got painfully obvious to me.
Dave, we don’t agree on a lot but we can agree one 4 things, Fuck the packers, pats, cowboys, and eagles.
I’m a Packers fan and read every word. If I’m gonna give other teams/their fans shit I gotta be able to take the lumps when it comes back.
Other Playoff Futility Teams:
1970s Vikings – Lost 4 Super Bowls,
1970s/80s Rams – Made the playoffs 14/20 Seasons; Only one Super Bowl Appearance
1980s Browns/Broncos- Red Right 88, The Mud Bowl, The Fumble, The Drive; Blown Out in 3 Super Bowls
1987-1994 Oilers- Made the playoffs 7 straight times, Never Made it past the 2nd round
1990s Lions- Made the playoffs 7 times; 1 playoff win
Andy Reid´s Eagles
Current Bills
Early 70s 49ers
1970
Make playoffs for the first time in 13 years (before that it was against the Lions in 1957 where they blew a 20pt lead)
Lose to the Cowboys in the NFC Champ. Final game at Keezar Stadium
1971
Another playoff appearance. Lose to the Cowboys in the NFC Champ. This time at Texas Stadium
1972
Play the defend champion Cowboys in Candlestick, this time in the divisional round. Go up 28-16. Landry puts in Staubach who missed most of the season due to injury. He leads the Cowboys to 2 late TDs. No playoffs for the 49ers for 9 years
Early 80s Cowboys
1980
Get revenge on the Rams for losing in Staubach’s final game
Be the cornerstone to the Falcons blowing leads in the playoffs (Duel In Dixie)
Be forced to wear blue jerseys in Philadelphia. Wouldn’t have happened if the Cowboys held on to their 35–10 lead vs PHI in season finale only to see it evaporate into a 35-27 W but a points tiebreaker gave the Eagles the NFC East & NFC-2
1981
12-4, NFC East, NFC-2
Blow out the Buccaneers in the divisional round
NFC Champ: Most folks remember the game as Montana to Clark for “The Catch”
One problem… there was less than a minute to play
Danny White hits Drew Pearson and for a brief moment it looks like Pearson is going to score. Eric Wright tackles him
49ers faithful think it’s 1972 all over again
Next play: Danny White sacked, fumbles, 49ers recover, they go on to beat the Bengals for their 1st of 4 titles in the 1980s
1982
Strike season
NFL Playoffs is 16-team playoffs w/8 per conference
NFC is pretty much chalk
NFC-1 WSH vs NFC-2 DAL at RFK
“WE WANT DALLAS!”
Hogs & John Riggins burry the Cowboys
Honorable mentions
1983
Last unbeaten team, lose to eventual Super Bowl champ OAK by 2 at home
“No, Danny. NO!”
Lose in the Wild Card to the Eric Dickerson Rams
1984
9-7
Landry engineers a QB controversey
Lose at winless BUF
Blow a lead at home vs WSH
Lose at MIA in final week to miss playoffs for 1st time since 1974
1985
44-0 vs CHI
Win NFC East, go to Rams & get ran over by Eric Dickerson
1984-88 Bears
1984: NFC Champ L at SF
1985: Win Super Bowl
1986-87: Home playoff Ls to WSH
1988: “Fog Bowl” vs PHI, NFC Champ L vs SF
1980s Bengals
2 Super Bowls vs SF, both Ls
1996-99 JAX
1996: Make AFC Champ, lose at NE
1997: Broncos get their revenge
1998: lose at NYJ in AFC Div
1999: 15-0 vs non Titans opponents. 0-3 vs Titans
Steelers during Patriots Brady-Belichick era (2000-19)
Make 3 Super Bowls, win 2
None of those Super Bowls runs involve facing the Patriots
When they faced each other, Steelers lose in the AFC Champ (2001, 2004, 2016)
Also in that run
Lose to JAX twice: 2007 (David Gerrard run), 2017 (Sacksonville)
2018: “Days of Our Steelers”
1990s Chiefs
Best season was 1993 where they lose at BUF in AFC Champ
2 first round exits at MIA
Lose at SD
Twice AFC-1. And done (1995 IND, 1997 DEN)
1999-02 Colts
Began narrative of “Can Manning win a playoff game?”
1999: Eddie George
2000: Vandershank
2001: PLAYOFFS?!
2002: 41-0 at NYJ
I was mainly talking about teams that never won a super bowl despite having many appearances in the postseason. Cowboys, Steelers, Bears, and Colts all would win the Super Bowl. Early 70s 49ers and late 90s Jacksonville is just too small to claim ¨Playoff Futility¨. 1990s Chiefs is a good answer.
I would have said the Jets and 90s Bills; but you already mae comics about them.
I feel like people need to go back and watch that Cardinals game and remember how elite Fitz was in his day. Feels like his career is being retconned as less than it was, when he was probably the 2nd greatest WR ever, maybe 3rd.
Larry Fitzgerald becoming somewhat of an afterthought is kind of poetic in way since he was always a very quiet and humble dude. He just went out and balled. No off-field nonsense. Never demanded a trade or got into fights with his carousel of Head Coaches. Always helped his many, many QBs. It doesn’t help that he never had a standout season either (not to say that he was mid, but he never led the league in receiving yards and only had a couple of seasons where he led in TDs or catches).
And of course his career ended the same way. Quiet, without much fanfare in a season where fans couldn’t even come to games. Hopefully the dude starts getting more love over time, since he absolutely deserves it as an all-time great WR, but I doubt he actually cares about all that.
This is the comic I was hoping to see after the Packers lost.
Was honestly hoping for an outcome that would have given us a 49ers train derailment, but this is a close second.
Packers fan here. That was a rough read. It really does show that even if you are super good, it can all come down to just one stupid thing, or just dumb luck.
But I do have to point out the massive missed facemask call in the 09-10 season. Brutal.
https://www.espn.com/blog/sportscenter/post/_/id/20996/packers-fans-upset-about-missed-face-mask-call
Also, that panel of Rodgers leaving belongs in MOMA. Fucking perfect.
Guh… Packers fan here and I read it all and now I need a drink.
As a Packers fan, I couldn’t agree with 90% of this blog post more. But I have to say I’d put the 2020 NFCCG way further down the list then you did. I get it’s Brady and all, but I was furious when we lost that game because we we’re definitely playing better in the second half and couldn’t capitalize on so many Bucs mistakes at all.
I read this entire post as a Packers fan because you can’t hurt me more than these losses already have. As you said this one wasn’t too bad and it actually inspires hope for the future
I was very torn when Green Bay lost to SF again. On the one hand, if Green Bay won, Fraudgers would have probably exploded a capillary and drowned in his own blood. That would have been GLORIIIIIIOUS.
But on the other hand, I absolutely cannot STAAAAAND the Packers fans I know when the team is successful. It’s the weirdest thing. When the team isn’t good, they’re pleasant to talk football with. But when the team starts winning and makes the postseason, it’s like some irrational psycho-chip activates, and they become entitlled a-holes. “You knowwww, we’ve just found AAAAaaahhhhhNOTHER great quarterback. Better start getting nervous again, NFL.” Actually, the same goes for Tom Grossi. I enjoy his content when GB stinks, but once they become good, he becomes this annoying jackass and I end up staring at the Unsubscribe button for minutes on end, pondering my life choices, lol.
Like, dudes, yea, ok, MAAYYYYYBE you have another great QB. MAYBE. I think we’ve learned that ONE successful season – no matter how good – is not enough to start chest thumping over. But also, what the hell. You won TWO Super Bowls with those amaaaaaaaaaaazing quarterbacks, and more often than not you got dunked on in the playoffs like chumps. Eli Manning has equaled your total championship output over those 30 years.
Jordan Love should start doing State Farm commercials if he wants to be better in the regular season and choke harder in the playoffs.
The most impressive thing about this comic is how you kept track of Rodger’s facial hair throughout the years.