CARTOON PICKS Week 18: It’s done, it’s finally over
And with that, the first 17 game season is over. It was kind of a waste to have an extra game, but it still gave us some drama. Raiders/Chargers was even better than expected, and we came inches away from a tie that would have sent Pittsburgh home. Alas. There isn’t much to learn, because now it’s just the playoffs. I’ll have the annual bandwagon guide up later this week for playoff discussion. Let’s just look at the results of my year!
My overall record: 172-99-1. Technically, I did not call the tie, but I also didn’t get it wrong, so I’m throwing it in there at the end. I was 63.4% accurate, which is actually an improvement from last year’s 61%. I’m surprised I improved, actually, because my middle season record is pretty bad. But I had several great weeks to bookend the year so I guess it worked out. This more or less tracks with how I expect most people’s picks to go. Early on, it’s easy to pick the teams you expect to be good and the early season hot teams, but around mid-season is when injuries and fortunes start to flip and the frauds are still mudding the waters. By the end of the year the teams are very clear so it’s no wonder my record improves there.
My worst week was week 10, where I went 5-8-1. I also went 7-8 in week 11, these were my only losing records. My week 9 was my only even split, at 7-7.
My best week was week 16, at 13-3.
Teams I had the least faith in: The Giants, of course. I never picked them to win a single game, and I got 4 wrong. Looking back, I would have picked those 4 games as losses again. That they beat anyone astounds me.
My best record: The Jets, for the second year in a row. I went 15-2 on the Jets, and surprisingly, I got both of their wins correct. My next best teams were the Falcons and Bears, both 14-3. After that, the Texans, Browns, Bucs, and Giants at 13-4. The Falcons and Bears being so high surprised me, because neither team was as clearly bad as say, the Jets or Texans. I just called their few wins pretty accurately.
My worst team…was not the Saints. The Saints and Chargers tied at 6-11 for my second-worst team. The Saints I knew would be bad, but the Chargers confounded me all year. But more than that, the team that clearly confused me the most…was the Raiders (4-13). I fucking hate the Raiders.
The team I underestimated the most (most incorrect Lose picks) was the Raiders, mostly through sheer volume of incorrect picks. 7 times I expected a loss and got burned. I also got the Titans wrong a lot, which makes sense, they looked dead in the water after Derrick Henry went down and the team became an injury revolving door. That they now own the #1 seed is amazing.
The team I expected too much from was the Raiders, Saints, and Panthers, who for each I got six called wins wrong. Basically, the Raiders, Panthers, Chargers, Saints, and Bengals were my losing records. My brain never computed the Bengals being successful.
I never picked the Bucs to lose. My longest win streak was the Jets, who I got right 10 weeks in a row.
Next up, PICKS. Had an average week. Sitting players will mess up choices in the standings. But I think I did some good work for this week.
Finally got my kneecaps drawing. Also, Urban Meyer grinding got me a lot of online attention this season, but I think Derek Car is my favorite new running joke this year.
PLAYOFFS! The game changes here. As those of you who followed me last year remember, now we get the good stuff. EVERY GAME GETS A PICTURE! It just depends on who wins. No more right and wrong, now you root for the picture.
RAIDERS @ BENGALS
I don’t know who is going to win this. I was incredibly wrong about both teams all year. I can’t even hazard a guess, I just hope the game rules.
If the Raiders win, I will draw Derek Car making a Bengal Tiger into roadkill
if the Bengals win, I will draw an old Bengals fan saying it’s been 84 years
PATRIOTS @ BILLS
Honestly kind of hilarious to me that this is the matchup we got. These two fought each other all year to control the division and now we get the final game to truly decide who walks away the champion. The Patriots were surprising this season, but faltered towards the end. The Bills disappointed all year, but grinded out wins that used to come easier. It feels like the pressure is on the Bills now. The Patriots are playing with house money, and I think they are gonna steal it.
If the Patriots win, I will draw the death star blowing up a herd of buffalo
if the Bills win, I will draw Josh Allen gleefully driving a covered wagon through a Patriots graveyard
EAGLES @ BUCS
I think the Eagles drew the short straw on first-round matchups. The birds have definitely found an identity in the second half of the year, but this is when Brady goes sicko mode.
If the Eagles win, I will draw Rocky punching Tom Brady in the face
if the Bucs win, I will draw an Eagle blasted out of the sky by a cannonball
49ERS @ COWBOYS
It felt like the Cowboys wanted to send a message in week 18 by pounding the birds into smithereens. The 49ers had to claw and scrape by the Rams to even obtain a playoff berth. I don’t see this ending well for the 49ers.
If the 49ers win, I will draw Yosemite Sam shooting the rich Texan from the Simpsons
if the Cowboys win, I will draw Gravekeeper Jerry Jones absorbing the lifeforce of Jimmy G
STEELERS @ CHIEFS
I hope the stupid Steelers get blown out the last thing I want is a Big Ben twilight glory tour. I want him obliterated like Dan Marino was in his last game. Luckily the Chiefs are the toughest matchup in the AFC right now, but this is far from guaranteed.
If the Steelers win, I will draw Big Ben riding a ketchup rocket into space
if the Chiefs win, I will draw Kermit Mahomes blowing up the big ben retirement tour hot air balloon with a bazooka
CARDINALS @ RAMS
The Rams have been disappointing but still strong. The Cardinals have become a disgrace. Probably the best the Rams could have hoped for.
If the Cardinals win, I will draw Kyler Murray as a phoenix, rising from the death of mediocrity
if the Rams win, I will draw Matthew Stafford crying over his first playoff W
Crazy how we were a needless timeout away from the Steelers missing the playoffs in the most Steelers way possible. Obligatory fuck Dean Spanos.
Yeah, I don’t know what Staley was thinking, there. The Raiders were clearly not trying to win, at that point. Just let them run out the clock and you BOTH go to the playoffs. Instead… the Chargers’ season is over.
The Raiders did literally the same thing on 3rd down as they did on the first two, it just worked better.
We were also a needless timeout away from the Raiders straight up winning in regulation. I almost think the Raiders were TRYING to boot the Steelers out of the playoffs
IMO the whole timeout controversy is overrated. After two consecutive runs up the middle, the Chargers call timeout with 4 seconds left on the play clock to… save time for a punt? And the timeout convinces the Raiders to go for the kill by… calling yet another run up the middle? One that was clearly gonna be stuffed until Jacobs cut back across the formation? I don’t buy it.
There’s a much simpler explanation there. Staley saw something he didn’t like when the teams lined up, called timeout, fixed it, and actually had a solid call on defense. Jacobs just made a good play, cut the run back and found a hole.
This is the correct take. Jacobs is a beast, he won that game for them.
what does blue mean? i figured purple is a tie but idk blue.
bye week
Love the “Shocker” symbol on the Urban Grinder.
That might be a reference to this guy – https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Urban_Shocker
Owner of one of the greatest names in Baseball History (right up there with Razor Shines, Rusty Kuntz and Pete La Cock).
Would you all stop with the idiotic timeout takes? There was 4 seconds left on the play clock.
My comment was more in reference to the whole “Fuck Spanos” joke but okay then.
Sure, the timeout didn’t really matter but it’s fun dunking on Dean Spanos.
Yeah I was starting to notice that you never picked the Giants! Also, so weird how celebrated Big Ben is. You go to Pittsburgh and you’ll see a lot of women wearing his jersey
Larry Fitzgerald should’ve gotten this walk off tour
I am sick to my stomach about the Bills Pats game. Absolutely NOT what I wanted, ugh. Living in Boston as a Bills fan can be just insufferable.
Buffalo should win unless the Football Gods team up with the Weather Gods again and let New England get away with running it 50 times like they did the first time around. New England’s defense can’t really handle the spread looks Buffalo runs and their pass rush has completely disappeared over the last few weeks. I’d be very surprised if NE pulled it out.
Wanna know how Fucked this season has been?
Brian Flores takes a team from 1-7 to 9-8, second straight winning season, does the double over the Patriots… and gets fired.
Joe Judge goes 4-13, a QB sneak on THIRD AND FUCKING NINE… and KEEPS his job.
Fuck me running.
I don’t think Flores wanted Tags. He wanted Herbert. And I don’t think he wanted Watson (breaking news: nobody wants that toxic filth).
Grier & Ross do – and Grier is in tight with Miami’s moron owner.
If they do sign Watson, I am officially done after 40 years as a Fin. I’ll stick with Tannehill and go with Tennessee; at least they have an idea how to protect their QBs…
There are reports that Watson wanted to play for Flores. Not sure I’m entirely convinced by them. Honestly, at this point, all I can hope for is that the legal system will take the Watson decision off of the Dolphins’ (and indeed, every other team’s) hands but if history has taught us anything, it’s that if a rich man commits crimes against women, he probably will get off free
Are you that really strong jaded dolphins fan in Dave’s older comics?
I can categorically deny that I have ever eaten Bland Joe Philbin Oatmeal Squares. Plus I’m not a redhead.
I do miss Marino though.
Coach Flo was the first Dolphins coach since fucking Dave Wanstedt in 2002 to have back-to-back winning seasons and he gets fired. He was legitimately the most fun coach since Sparano. God damn, I can’t believe it.
In fairness, I don’t think comparing the Giants keeping Judge thru yesterday is comparable to the Dolphins dumping Flores. For one thing, Johnny Mara squints so hard that his eyeballs popped out, and he therefore cannot see. He kept Judge because he didn’t know what day it was yesterday, and also because he was enamored with the sound of the adulant crowd chanting his name for giving out free medium pepsis, and thus did not hear about the victory formation in the shadow of their own endzone.
And BESIDES, I’ll bet you hard money that those Dolphins players were planning vacations and had, just… just… BAGS upon BAGS filled with golf clubs stacked up. I bet you couldn’t even get to the weight room, there were so many golf clubs. You don’t see none of that in NJ, because we’re not a clown organization, like you guys. You guys and all your… golf clubs.
Well kept but good point
Why is Trevor Lawrence dressed like Antonio Brown?
The fans dressed like clowns
If you would’ve followed the coin predictions you’d be 15-2. 🙂
Jags fans were dressed as clowns
Antonio Brown tribute
Fuck yeah I see that Tree happily Urinating in the background